True crime podcasts are everywhere these days, and honestly, I can’t get enough. There’s something so gripping about hearing these wild stories unravel, piece by piece. If you’re already hooked or just curious about where to start, I’ve got you covered with some of the best true crime podcasts out there.
1. RedHanded
First up, my top pick: RedHanded with Hannah Maguire and Suruthi Bala. This podcast is an absolute gem. These two are a dream team, bringing you deep dives into some of the most fascinating true crime cases. They’re hilarious, razor-sharp, and they’ve got this incredible knack for balancing grim topics with just the right amount of humour.
From high-profile cases to totally obscure ones, Hannah and Suruthi go all in with top-notch research and thoughtful discussions. They also explore the bigger picture – societal issues, psychology, and more. It’s like having the smartest, funniest friends walk you through a crime case. Trust me, if you’re not already listening, you’re missing out.
2. Criminal
Phoebe Judge’s Criminal is a classic for a reason. This podcast isn’t just about murder and mayhem (though there’s plenty of that too). It covers all kinds of fascinating crime stories – think art thefts, fraud, and even quirky historical cases. Phoebe’s voice is like a warm hug, and the storytelling is always top-tier. Perfect for those who like their true crime a bit outside the box.
3. Casefile
For those who prefer a no-frills approach, Casefile is your go-to. The anonymous Australian host tells each story with just the facts, letting the cases speak for themselves. It’s super detailed and perfect if you like a serious, straightforward vibe. Plus, the variety of cases means there’s always something new and interesting to dive into.
4. Morbid: A True Crime Podcast
If you love a bit of humour with your horror, Morbid is the one for you. Hosted by Alaina Urquhart and Ashleigh Kelley, this podcast is like a true crime sleepover with your best friends. They bring plenty of laughs while still being super respectful about the cases they cover. It’s lighthearted but still hits the true crime sweet spot.
5. The Last Podcast on the Left
This one’s for the fans of the weird and the wild. The Last Podcast on the Left mixes true crime with supernatural stories, conspiracy theories, and just plain bizarre stuff. The hosts, Ben Kissel, Marcus Parks, and Henry Zebrowski, are hilarious and totally unfiltered. It’s not everyone’s cup of tea, but if you’re up for something different, give it a go.
6. My Favourite Murder
Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark’s My Favourite Murder feels like chatting with your crime-obsessed mates. The conversational style is super relatable, and their mix of humour and compassion makes even the darkest stories feel approachable. Plus, their fanbase (the “Murderinos”) is awesome, so you’ll feel right at home.
Why RedHanded Is My Favourite
So, back to RedHanded. It’s honestly everything I want in a true crime podcast. Hannah and Suruthi have this effortless chemistry, and their storytelling skills are unmatched. They don’t just rehash the details; they dig into the “why” behind it all. Add in their sharp humour and thoughtful insights, and you’ve got podcast gold.
Seriously, if you’re new to true crime or just looking for your next binge, RedHanded should be at the top of your list. You’ll be hooked from episode one.
Your Turn
Got a true crime podcast you can’t stop listening to? I’d love to hear about it! Drop your recommendations in the comments so we can all add something new to our playlists. True crime is always better when shared, right?
K Eleanor | Author 
Leave a comment